Why Autumn Is the Time to Get Your Bird Feeding Right
As the nights draw in and natural food becomes scarcer, garden birds rely more and more on what we put out. Insects disappear, berries run out, and a frosty morning can mean birds burn through their energy reserves quickly. Putting out the right mix of seed and fat from October onwards can make a real difference, and it turns a quiet patch of garden into one of the best bits of free entertainment going.
The problem is the sheer choice. Seed mixes, sunflower hearts, suet pellets, fat balls, mealworms – they all look similar on the shelf, but they suit different feeders and different birds. This guide pulls together seven popular options we would feel comfortable recommending, and explains what each is best for.
At a Glance: Bird Foods Compared
Prices are approximate and change with stock and pack size, so use them as a guide to relative value.
| Product | Type | Best For | Approx Price |
| Peckish Natural Balance Energy Balls (50) | Fat balls | Standard hanging feeders | around £8-12 |
| RSPB Fat Balls | Suet balls | Conservation-minded buyers | around £11-15 |
| Peckish Natural Balance Seed Mix 12.75kg | General seed mix | Busy mixed feeders | around £13-17 |
| Extra Select Wild Bird Seed Mix | Seed with black sunflower | Better-quality all-rounder | around £13-17 |
| Garden Ting Sunflower Hearts 5L | Husk-free hearts | Tidy patios and lawns | around £10-14 |
| RSPB Suet Pellets | Suet pellets | Mixed feeders and ground trays | around £11-15 |
| Supa Dried Mealworms 1L | Protein treat | Robins, wrens, blackbirds | around £5-8 |
The Products, One by One
1. Peckish Natural Balance Energy Balls (50 Box)
Peckish is one of the most widely stocked wild bird food brands in the UK, and its Natural Balance fat balls are the sort of product you will find in most garden centres and supermarkets. This box of 50 is a sensible way to stock up for the colder months without paying per-ball prices.
Pros: Widely trusted UK brand, 50 balls last a good while on a single feeder, easy to find and re-order.
Cons: Budget-priced balls tend to be softer in mild weather, so they can crumble if left in direct sun, and a box of 50 needs dry storage.
Who it suits: anyone who wants a dependable, affordable all-rounder fat ball for a standard hanging feeder.
- This product contains 100% natural ingredients.
- These energy suet fat balls are enriched with sunflower seeds to attract more birds to your garden.
- Suitable to be fed to birds all year round.
- This feed can be fed to wild birds from a energy ball feeder, bird table or the ground.
2. RSPB Fat Balls, High Energy Suet Balls
Buying RSPB-branded food is a simple way to put money back into bird conservation, and these suet balls are made in the UK. They sit at the premium end of the fat ball range, so they are not the cheapest per ball, but they are a good choice if you want to feed with a clear conscience and reliably consistent quality.
Pros: Backed by the RSPB, made in the UK, consistent quality, a good choice if you also want to support conservation work.
Cons: Costs more per ball than supermarket-style multipacks, and the pack size is smaller than the bulk boxes.
Who it suits: gardeners who prefer to buy from a conservation charity brand and do not mind paying a little extra.
- ENERGY RICH TREATS: High in fat, these suet balls for birds are packed with essential energy for your feathered friends, helping them stay active and healthy all year round
- MADE IN THE UK: Wild bird feed with a nutritious blend of suet, wheat flour, ground peanuts, millet seed, rapeseed and linseed. Carefully crafted suet balls that ensure birds get vital nutrients they need.
- FAT BALLS FOR BIRDS: Suitable for year-round feeding from suet feeders, these versatile bird balls can be put out whole, loose, or crumbled. Perfect for small birds and garden birds - the ideal choice for your backyard bird care.
- RSPB: Dedicated to the conservation of birds and nature. Our suet bird food products are nature-friendly, containing healthy and delicious ingredients free of harmful chemicals and toxins, ensuring the best for your garden birds.
- GREAT FOR BIRD WATCHING: Attracts a wide variety of common garden birds, such as Blackbirds, Blue Tits, Robins, and Starlings. Watch as your garden comes to life with a flurry of colour and vitality.
3. Peckish Natural Balance Seed Mix, 12.75kg
A big bag of general-purpose seed mix is the backbone of most bird feeding routines. This 12.75kg Peckish bag is designed as an all-year mix and suits standard seed feeders and ground feeding trays. Bulk bags like this are far better value than small tubs, as long as you have somewhere dry and rodent-proof to keep them.
Pros: Good value per kilo, suits most standard seed feeders, easy to top up daily during winter.
Cons: Mixes with cheaper grain fillers can mean some seed is left on the ground and wasted, and a 12.75kg bag is heavy to carry and store.
Who it suits: households feeding a busy mix of tits, finches, sparrows and robins through the season.
- This bird food mix is enriched with sunflower seeds along will seven other seeds
- Made from 100 Percent natural ingredients
- Use this seed to attract Blackbird, Robin, House Sparrow, Long Tailed Tit, Chaffinch, Song Thrush, Blue Tit and Tit plus many more birds to your garden
- Can be fed to birds either from a bird seed feeder on a bird table or in a ground tray
- Available as a 1.7 kg, 4 kg or 12.75 kg
4. Extra Select Wild Bird Seed Mix with Black Sunflower Seeds
Extra Select positions itself as a step up from standard supermarket seed mixes, with black sunflower seeds in the blend. Black sunflower is a favourite with many garden birds, and a mix that leans on it tends to leave less discarded filler under the feeder than a grain-heavy bag.
Pros: Black sunflower seeds included, a higher-quality feel than basic mixes, suits a wide range of garden birds.
Cons: More expensive than the cheapest bulk mixes, so it is worth buying only if you will use the bag within a few months.
Who it suits: anyone who wants a better-quality mix without moving to fully premium or specialist feeds.
- Nutrient-Rich Blend: Specially formulated with black sunflower seeds, cut maize, and white millet.
- Winter Boost: Provides essential nutrients that help feed birds like robins through the harsh winter months.
- Crafted for Garden Birds: Ideal birdseed for small garden birds like sparrows, finches and dunnocks.
- All-Season Feeding: Perfect as wild bird food for small birds all year round.
- High Protein Content: Our bird feed contains 13% protein to support wild bird growth and vitality.
5. Garden Ting Sunflower Hearts Wild Bird Food, 5 Litre
Sunflower hearts are husk-free kernels, so there is no shell mess under the feeder and very little waste. Many birdwatchers consider them one of the best single foods you can put out, as tits, finches and many others take them readily. This 5 litre bag is a manageable size for gardeners who want to try hearts before committing to a large sack.
Pros: No husks to clear up, very little waste, popular with a wide range of garden birds.
Cons: Pricier per kilo than whole-seed mixes, and sparrows and starlings can empty a feeder quickly.
Who it suits: tidy gardeners with feeders over patios or lawns who want to avoid shell mess.
- Generous Supply: Garden Ting's sunflower hearts are packed in a practical 5-litre tub, providing a generous supply of bird food
- Durable Reusable Tub: The reusable tub is made from durable materials, allowing for long-term use and reducing plastic waste
- Nutrient-Rich Formula: Sunflower hearts are rich in essential nutrients, promoting the health and well-being of garden birds
- Convenient Storage Solution: The 5-litre tub ensures convenient storage and easy access to sunflower hearts whenever needed
- Attracts Multiple Species: Garden Ting's sunflower hearts attract a wide range of bird species, including finches, robins, and blue tits
6. RSPB Suet Pellets for Small Birds
Suet pellets offer the same high-energy benefit as fat balls but pour straight into a feeder or ground tray, so there is no net or ball to deal with. They suit mixed feeders, and the RSPB version is made in the UK. They are handy on cold mornings when birds need to take on energy quickly.
Pros: Easy to pour and top up, no netting, suits a wide range of feeders and ground trays.
Cons: Can go off in prolonged warm weather, so avoid filling a feeder to the brim in mild spells.
Who it suits: gardeners with a mix of feeder types who want one food that suits all of them.
- CONSERVING NATURE: The RSPB is always striving to do more for nature and wildlife, helping to save species and habitats across the UK. When you buy from the RSPB, you’re not only feeding your garden birds, but also supporting our vital conservation work.
- ENERGY-RICH TREATS: Bursting with natural goodness, the wild bird suet pellets are packed with energy and protein for your feathered friends, helping them to stay active and healthy year-round.
- MADE IN THE UK: The bird food suet pellets contain premium suet that will be hard for birds to resist. The carefully crafted high energy bird food ensures birds get the vital nutrients they need.
- VERSATILE: The suet bird food is suitable for year-round feeding from mesh feeders or sprinkled on the ground. The wild bird feed is perfect for small birds and garden birds - the ideal choice for your backyard bird care.
- GREAT FOR BIRD WATCHING: Attracts a wide variety of common garden birds, such as coal tits, blue tits, robins, and song thrushes. Watch as your garden comes to life with a flurry of colour and vitality.
7. Supa Dried Mealworms for Wild Birds, 1 Litre Bucket
Dried mealworms are a high-protein treat that robins, blackbirds, wrens and tits will often take eagerly. They are best offered in a small dish or a dedicated mealworm feeder, and soaking them briefly in water in dry weather is a common tip among bird feeders. A 1 litre bucket is a sensible trial size.
Pros: Popular with robins and blackbirds, handy as a protein top-up, small bucket is easy to store.
Cons: Not a replacement for a main feed, and starlings and magpies may take them quickly if the dish is exposed.
Who it suits: anyone who wants to attract insect-eating birds such as robins and wrens.
- 100% Natural High Protein Treat: Supa Dried Mealworms 1 Litre are a 100% natural highly nutritious protein rich treat for Wild Birds that will attract birds to your garden all year round
- Versatile Feeding Options: Dried Mealworms can be fed as a treat or can be mixed in with other seed or suet pellets
- Minimal Wastage: Since garden birds enjoy Dried Mealworms so much, there is hardly any wastage
- Attracts Multiple Bird Species: The type of birds that will be attracted to feed on the Dried Mealworms are: Robins, Sparrows, Blackbirds, Blue Tits, Great Tits, Starlings plus many more varieties of birds
- Reusable Storage Container: The reusable 1 Litre plastic bucket avoids waste & mess and keeps the feed fresh
Buying Guide: Choosing the Right Bird Food
Match the food to the feeder
Seed mixes and sunflower hearts suit tube or hopper feeders. Fat balls need a dedicated cage-style feeder, while suet pellets and mealworms work well in a tray or a mixed feeder. Buying food that does not fit what you already own is the most common reason people end up with a half-used bag in the shed.
Take the netting off fat balls
Netting can trap beaks, tongues and feet, which is why wildlife charities generally recommend loose fat balls in a proper feeder rather than mesh-wrapped ones. Whichever brand you buy, check the pack and take off any netting before filling a feeder.
Price per kilo, not per bag
A small tub of premium seed can look cheap until you compare it with a big sack. Work out the cost per kilo, then decide how much you will realistically use. Seed that sits in a damp shed goes mouldy, and mouldy food can harm birds.
Store it dry and rodent-proof
Keep bulk bags in a lidded bin or a secure garden storage box, away from damp. A metal bin with a tight lid is a good option if you have had problems with mice or rats, and a shed shelf off the floor helps too.
Keep feeders clean
Whichever food you buy, clean feeders regularly with warm soapy water and let them dry, to reduce the spread of disease between birds. Moving a feeder to a fresh spot every so often keeps droppings from building up beneath it.
Our Recommendation
For a straightforward starter setup, the Peckish seed mix and the Peckish fat balls cover most garden birds at a low cost, while the Garden Ting sunflower hearts are the best choice if you want a tidy, low-waste feed. If you want to support conservation at the same time, the RSPB fat balls and suet pellets are the ones to pick, and a small bucket of mealworms is a cheap way to bring robins close to the kitchen window.
More Garden Reviews
Looking for more? These related MyGreenShed guides are worth a read next:
